Natural previews: swatch 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6
Supernatural previews: swatch 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 6
An anon on tumblr requested defaults of these eyes, and I got a little carried away.
There are from 3 to 4 choices for each natural eye color. The werewolf eyes come with Maxis' face texture (since apparently werewolf skins work like facepaint... the more you know), Vampires have no skin overlays, and plantsims and genies use Leh's skins. That means that if you're using different skin defaults for plantsims and werewolves, your sims will have mismatched bodies and faces. Nothing I can do about it, I'm sorry.
All eyes have Maxis' sclera; werewolves have a darker one, and plantsims have green-tinted ones.
Remisims for the supernatural .package files, which I used as templates